The 7 Best Cake Shops in Maine!

If you’re looking for a decorative, delicious, custom-made cake for your next special occasion, Maine is your place. Whether it’s a wedding, baby shower, or birthday party, these seven excellent cake shops in Maine have you covered with their sinfully good cakes. 

1. Beach Pea Baking Co., Kittery, ME

Located in Kittery, Beach Pea Baking Co. strives to produce only the best handcrafted breads, cakes, and pastries. The bakery uses ingredients found locally whenever possible. Beach Pea makes specially ordered cakes, including wedding cakes, without the use of fondant. Patrons love their cake flavors like almond mocha and lemon Chambord. And, the homemade buttercream frosting is just to die for!

2. Cake Elizabeth, Cape Elizabeth, ME

Who doesn’t love a good pun? Cake Elizabeth creates custom cakes baked fresh daily. Choose from over 13 flavors and 20 gourmet toppings to create the perfect cake for your special occasion. And if you don’t like cake, try one of the 28 different flavors of cupcakes.

3. 3 Dogs Café, Rockport, ME

Open seven days a week year-round, 3 Dogs Café in coastal Rockport specializes in French pastries, baked goods, celebration cakes, and custom-designed wedding cakes. Cakes are affordable and fully customizable. Choose from a range of cake and frosting flavors. 

4. Marta’s Bakery, Waterford, ME

Located in western Maine, Marta’s Bakery has made hundreds of wedding and birthday cakes over the years. Originally from Czechoslovakia and trained in Boston, Marta and her family moved to Waterford where she opened her own bakery. Her cakes are known to be delicious and beautiful. 

5. Heather’s Bakery, Poland, ME

Decorating cakes since 1999, Heather’s Bakery in Poland is one of the best home bakeries in the state. Over the years, she has designed and decorated thousands of cakes for special occasions and weddings. Heather offers a range of classic flavors like white, chocolate, and marble, and other special flavor mixes. 

6. Confectionately Yours, Presque Isle, ME

Confectionately Yours is the best custom-made cake shop in northern Maine. Kelly’s cakes taste as good as they look. Her motto is “the sky’s the limit” so give her challenge. She can make everything from children’s birthday cakes to wedding cakes. Just look at her gallery on Facebook for some ideas. Have a food allergy? Kelly can accommodate that, too. 

7. Let Them Eat Cake, Kennebunk, ME

Let Them Eat Cake is a force to reckon with when it comes to custom cake. Brides Magazine featured them in the “Top 100 Cake Designers in the U.S.,” and named them the “Best Cake Designer in Maine.” Other accolades include Martha Stewart Weddings “Top Pastry Pros,” and several WeddingWire Couples’ Choice and Bride’s Choice awards. 

View more Maine Bakeries and Pastry Shops.
Share your favorites!
Maine Search
Find Bakeries and Pastry Shops Near You
Select a Maine town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you